Building up Germany's Censorship Infrastructure
Maybe you've not heard yet that Germany is currently building up a censorship infrastructure for the internet under the pretext to fight child porn. The following article from netzpolitik.org summarizes the problem very well (source
). This topic is quite critical, so here is a full quote of the article:
Germany is on the verge of censoring its Internet: The government – a grand coalition between the German social democrats and conservative party – seems united in its decision: On Thursday the parliament is to vote on the erection of an internet censorship architecture.
The Minister for Family Affairs Ursula von der Leyen
kicked off and lead the discussions within the German Federal Government to block Internet sites in order to fight child pornography. The general idea is to build a censorship architecture enabling the government to block content containing child pornography. The Federal Office of Criminal Investigation (BKA) is to administer the lists of sites to be blocked and the internet providers obliged to erect the secret censorship architecture for the government.
A strong and still growing network opposing these ideas quickly formed within the German internet community. The protest has not been limited to hackers and digital activist but rather a mainstreamed effort widely supported by bloggers and twitter-users. The HashTag used by the protesters is #zensursula
– a German mesh up of the Ministers name and the word censorship equivalent to #censursula.
As part of the public’s protest an official e-Petition directed at the German parliament was launched. Within three days 50,000 persons signed the petition - – the number required for the petition titled „No indexing and blocking of Internet sites
“ to be heard by the parliament. The running time of an e-Petition in Germany is 6 weeks – within this time over 130,000 people signed making this e-Petition the most signed and most successful ever.
During the past weeks, protests became more and more creative – countless blogs and twitter-users followed and commented the discussions within governments and opposing arguments. Many mainstream media picked up on this and reported about the protest taking place on-line. A working group on censorship
was founded and the protest coordinated with a wiki
, mailing lists, chats and of course employing twitter and blogs. One website „Zeichnemit.de
“ created a landing page explaining the complicated petitioning system and making signing the petition easier and more accessible for non net-experts.
Over 500 people attended the governments official press conference on the planed internet censorship – a number of whom used this occasion to demonstrate and voice their concerns. In fact, demonstrators began attending some of the Minister von der Leyens public appearances, carrying banners and signs to raise attention
to the stifling of information freedom in Germany.
The net community did not only oppose the governments plans, but also made constructive suggestions how to deal with the problem of child pornography without introducing a censorship architecture and circumcising constitutional freedoms. The working group on censorship demonstrated the alternatives for instance by actually removing over 60 websites containing child pornographic content in 12 hours, simply by emailing the international providers who then removed this content from the net. The sites were identified through the black lists of other countries documented on Wikileaks. This demonstration underlines the protesters main arguments: instead of effectively investing time and efforts to have illegal content removed from the internet, the German government is choosing censorship and blocking – an easy and dangerous way out. The greatest fear of the protesters is that once in place, the infrastructure will be used to censor other forms of unwanted content, not only child pornography. German politicians already seem to be lining up with their wish-list of content to be censored in future – the suggestions ranging form gambling sites, islamist web pages, first person shooters, and the music industry cheering up with the thought of finally banning pirate bay and p2p.
Find more info here
eight comments, already:
Don’t vote SPD or CDU/CSU!
Blah - 17 06 09 - 14:36
Germany is sometimes hilarious. All violence in films is strictly censored, even very late at night (i.e. 2:00 or 3:00 a.m). Scarface or Starship troopers are two of the latest films that diffent German channels have ruined me… But you zap to another channel and you can see a grandma introducing herself a dildo…
Mark - 18 06 09 - 00:17
There has been a lot of talk of doing something similar here in Australia to fight child pornography. A ‘black-list’ approach has been developed and trialled by some ISPs, but the list was leaked on wikileaks a while ago and it showed that while a portion of sites were related to child porn, many other sites were simply legitimate porn websites or just contained ‘offensive’ material such as graphic anti-abortion websites and so on.
Most ISPs have said the idea is simply stupid and will lead to reduced traffic capacity, and many people here are strongly opposed to the government being able to block any content they deem inappropriate. Personally I doubt something like this will ever happen on a large scale here.
Joseph () - 18 06 09 - 01:04
“Don’t vote SPD or CDU/CSU!”
Exactly. I agree and I do so. But the majority of Germans will vote like the ever do. They are like dinosaurs, cannot adapt and steer into extinction.
“All violence in films is strictly censored, ... but … you can see a grandma introducing herself a dildo…”
This is fine to me. Violence in real life kills people but using a Dildo is just fun and does no harm at all. Only old-school Christians and other religions might have problem with sex. But actually it is a natural, healthy and birth-giving process (except you use a dildo ).
Frank - 18 06 09 - 09:28
They added similar black list here in Finland too to block child porn sites. However, the list is kept secret from public and apparently a lot of non-child porn sites are also on the list including a certain activist who has been fighting against the censorship by publishing the list.
So yea, it’s a failure. Yet nobody can protest against it without being marked as supporter of child pornography.
Suvi - 18 06 09 - 10:29
Today marks the day where 130000 signatures in the petition against will simply be ignored. At 16:45 the debate will start. 45 Minutes later, it will be over. The law will have passed.
It will probably be removed by the Federal Constitutional Court, later. But the damage will still be permanent.
Tazo - 18 06 09 - 14:13
The United States are sometimes hilarious. All forms of erotics in films is strictly censored, even very late at night (i.e. 2:00 or 3:00 a.m.)... but you zap to another channel and you can see a man being ripped apart by zombies…
Sylence () (link) - 18 06 09 - 17:29
you mean you dont support zombie rights?!
sRc - 18 06 09 - 22:00